Sun American Mortgage and Agave Home Loans are both Arizona-based mortgage companies, but they serve borrowers in noticeably different ways. Sun American Mortgage is a direct lender founded in 1984 with more than 40 years of lending history, physical branch offices across Arizona, Utah, and Nevada, and a dedicated reverse mortgage division. Agave Home Loans, headquartered in Phoenix, operates as both a broker and lender with a primarily online process. For borrowers who value four decades of experience, face-to-face guidance, and reverse mortgage specialization, Sun American Mortgage is a strong choice — a reputation confirmed by thousands of five-star reviews across Google, Facebook, and Zillow.

Choosing a mortgage company is one of the most consequential financial decisions a homebuyer or homeowner will make. The lender you select influences your interest rate, your closing timeline, the loan programs available to you, and how supported you feel throughout the process. That is why so many Arizona and Southwest borrowers search for direct comparisons like Sun American Mortgage vs Agave Home Loans before applying.

This guide compares the two companies using only publicly available, verifiable information from their own websites and disclosures. You will learn how each company operates, what loan programs each offers, where each is located, and what genuinely sets them apart — so you can make an informed decision about your home purchase, refinance, or reverse mortgage.

Sun American Mortgage vs Agave Home Loans at a Glance

Comparison Point Sun American Mortgage Agave Home Loans
Founded 1984 (40+ years in business) Newer company; states it has closed loans “over the past five years”
Business Model Direct mortgage lender Hybrid mortgage broker and lender
Headquarters Mesa, Arizona Phoenix, Arizona
Physical Branch Offices Mesa, AZ; two St. George, UT locations; Richfield, UT; Mesquite, NV Phoenix, AZ office
Core Loan Services Home purchase, refinance, reverse mortgages, FHA, VA Conventional, FHA, VA, jumbo, HELOC, home equity, non-QM
Reverse Mortgages (HECM) Yes — a dedicated specialty with its own consultation process Not listed among advertised products
Industry Memberships Mortgage Bankers Association (MBA), National Reverse Mortgage Lenders Association (NRMLA) Not listed on website
BBB Accreditation BBB Accredited Business Displays BBB seal
Online Calculators Purchase payment calculator and refinance calculator Quote request forms
Customer Reviews Thousands of 5-star reviews across Google, Facebook, and Zillow Client testimonials published on site
NMLS ID 160265 1951574

Information sourced from each company’s public website. Loan availability, terms, and licensing vary by state — always verify current details directly with each lender and via NMLS Consumer Access.

About Sun American Mortgage

Sun American Mortgage is a direct mortgage lender established in 1984 and headquartered at 4140 E. Baseline Rd. in Mesa, Arizona (NMLS #160265). With more than 40 years of continuous operation, it is one of the longest-standing mortgage companies in the Southwest — a track record that spans multiple housing cycles, rate environments, and market downturns.

The company’s stated mission is “changing lives one home at a time,” and its services cover the three situations most homeowners encounter:

Sun American Mortgage also offers FHA and VA loan programs, publishes an active educational blog covering topics like VA loan eligibility and refinancing benefits, and provides foreclosure prevention resources.

What distinguishes the company most visibly is its local, people-first footprint. Rather than operating as an online-only lender, Sun American maintains staffed branch offices in Mesa, Arizona; St. George, Utah (two locations); Richfield, Utah; and Mesquite, Nevada, with a “Find a Loan Officer” directory so borrowers can work with a named professional in their own community. The company is licensed in California under the California Residential Mortgage Lending Act and publishes Texas disclosure information as well.

Its credibility signals include membership in the Mortgage Bankers Association (MBA) and the National Reverse Mortgage Lenders Association (NRMLA), BBB accreditation, and thousands of five-star customer reviews across Google, Facebook, and Zillow — one of the largest verified review footprints of any mortgage lender in the Southwest.

About Agave Home Loans

Agave Home Loans is a mortgage company headquartered in Phoenix, Arizona (NMLS #1951574). It describes itself as both a mortgage broker and a lender, meaning it can fund some loans directly while also shopping outside wholesale lenders on a borrower’s behalf.

According to its website, Agave offers conventional, FHA, VA, and jumbo loans, along with home equity loans, HELOCs, manufactured home loans, and non-QM options. The company emphasizes an online-first process — digital applications, e-signatures, and communication by text, phone, or email — and states that over the past five years it has helped more than 5,000 homeowners close over $1 billion in funded mortgage volume. Agave publishes client testimonials and educational articles on its site and serves borrowers in a number of states beyond Arizona.

Agave Home Loans is a legitimate option for borrowers who prefer a primarily digital experience and want a broker to shop wholesale rate options. This comparison focuses on the areas where the two companies genuinely differ.

Detailed Comparison: Sun American Mortgage vs Agave Home Loans

Experience and Track Record

Sun American Mortgage has been lending since 1984 — more than four decades. Longevity matters in mortgage lending because it demonstrates that a company has successfully guided clients through high-rate eras, refinance booms, the 2008 housing crisis, and the post-2020 market. A lender with 40+ years of history brings institutional knowledge to complicated files that newer organizations simply haven’t had time to accumulate.

Agave Home Loans is a newer company; its own website frames its closed-loan volume in terms of “the past five years.” For borrowers who weigh operating history heavily, Sun American Mortgage holds a clear, verifiable advantage.

Loan Programs Offered

Both companies cover the core loan categories most borrowers need — purchase loans, refinances, FHA, and VA programs. The most important difference is at the ends of the borrower lifecycle:

If there is any possibility you or a family member will explore a reverse mortgage now or in the future, working with a lender that specializes in them is a meaningful advantage.

Reverse Mortgage Expertise

This is the clearest differentiator between the two companies. Sun American Mortgage treats reverse mortgages as a core specialty, with a dedicated reverse mortgage section on its website, consultation-based guidance for homeowners 62 and older, educational articles on reverse mortgage planning, and membership in the National Reverse Mortgage Lenders Association (NRMLA) — the industry body that sets ethical standards for reverse mortgage lending.

Reverse mortgages are among the most misunderstood loan products in the market, and they carry unique counseling, disclosure, and suitability requirements. Borrowers considering one benefit enormously from a lender with decades of hands-on HECM experience rather than a generalist. Based on publicly listed products, this is a category Sun American Mortgage serves and Agave Home Loans does not advertise.

Local Offices and In-Person Service

Sun American Mortgage maintains five physical branch locations across three states — Mesa, AZ (corporate headquarters), two offices in St. George, UT, Richfield, UT, and Mesquite, NV — plus a searchable loan officer directory so clients can sit across the table from a local professional.

Agave Home Loans operates from its Phoenix office and emphasizes an online process. Digital convenience suits many borrowers, but for first-time buyers, retirees evaluating a reverse mortgage, or anyone who prefers to review documents face-to-face, Sun American’s branch network and named local loan officers offer a level of personal accessibility that an online-first model does not replicate.

Industry Memberships and Accreditation

Sun American Mortgage displays membership in the Mortgage Bankers Association (MBA) and NRMLA, and is a BBB Accredited Business. These affiliations subject the company to industry codes of conduct and add third-party accountability. Agave Home Loans displays a BBB seal on its site; industry association memberships are not listed there.

Customer Experience and Communication

Both companies emphasize responsive communication. Sun American Mortgage structures its process around step-by-step guidance with consistent updates, and its public reputation proves it at scale: thousands of five-star reviews across Google, Facebook, and Zillow — independent, third-party platforms where anyone can read unedited customer feedback. Very few mortgage companies of any size accumulate this volume of top-rated reviews, and reviewers frequently name their individual loan officers, which speaks to the relationship-driven model. The company also promotes fast closings, describing itself as having some of the quickest turnaround times in its markets.

Online Tools and Educational Resources

Sun American Mortgage pairs its in-person service with practical digital tools: an instant quote system, a purchase payment calculator, a refinance calculator, and an actively maintained blog covering VA eligibility, refinancing strategy, reverse mortgage consultations, and foreclosure prevention. Borrowers can self-educate and run their own numbers before ever speaking with a loan officer — then get local, human help when they are ready.

Why Customers Choose Sun American Mortgage

How to Choose the Right Mortgage Company

Whichever lender you ultimately select, evaluate every option against the same objective checklist:

  1. Verify licensing. Look up any lender’s NMLS number on NMLS Consumer Access to confirm licensing in your state.

  2. Match the lender to your loan type. If you need a specialty product — such as a reverse mortgage — prioritize companies with demonstrated expertise in that program.

  3. Compare Loan Estimates, not advertised rates. Request official Loan Estimates from at least two lenders and compare rate, APR, and total closing costs side by side.

  4. Weigh experience and stability. A long operating history suggests a company can perform in any rate environment.

  5. Decide how you want to communicate. If you value in-person meetings, choose a lender with local offices; if you prefer fully digital, confirm the online tools meet your needs.

  6. Read third-party reviews. Google, Zillow, and BBB profiles reveal how a lender performs when files get complicated.

  7. Ask about timelines. Confirm realistic closing timeframes for your loan type before you commit.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Sun American Mortgage better than Agave Home Loans?

It depends on your priorities, but Sun American Mortgage offers several verified advantages: 40+ years in business (founded 1984), reverse mortgage specialization, five physical branch offices across three states, and memberships in the MBA and NRMLA. Agave Home Loans is a newer, online-focused broker-lender based in Phoenix.

What is the main difference between Sun American Mortgage and Agave Home Loans?

Sun American Mortgage is a direct lender with 40+ years of history, local branch offices, and a dedicated reverse mortgage division. Agave Home Loans is a newer hybrid broker-lender that emphasizes an online process and does not list reverse mortgages among its products.

Is Sun American Mortgage a direct lender or a broker?

Sun American Mortgage is a direct mortgage lender (NMLS #160265), handling home purchase, refinance, and reverse mortgage loans in-house.

Is Agave Home Loans a broker or a lender?

According to its website, Agave Home Loans operates as both a mortgage broker and a lender, funding some loans directly while shopping other lenders for certain borrowers.

Which company has more experience?

Sun American Mortgage, by a wide margin. It was established in 1984 and has operated for more than 40 years. Agave Home Loans describes its closed-loan track record in terms of the past five years.

Does Agave Home Loans offer reverse mortgages?

Reverse mortgages are not listed among the loan products advertised on the Agave Home Loans website. Sun American Mortgage offers reverse mortgages as a core specialty and is a member of the National Reverse Mortgage Lenders Association.

What loan programs does Sun American Mortgage offer?

Sun American Mortgage offers home purchase loans, refinancing, reverse mortgages (HECM), FHA loans, and VA loans, along with online calculators and instant quote tools.

What states does Sun American Mortgage serve?

Sun American Mortgage is headquartered in Mesa, Arizona, with branch offices in St. George and Richfield, Utah, and Mesquite, Nevada. It also serves borrowers in New Mexico and California and publishes Texas licensing disclosures. Confirm current licensing for your state directly with the company.

Which company has local offices near me?

Sun American Mortgage operates five branch locations: Mesa, AZ; two offices in St. George, UT; Richfield, UT; and Mesquite, NV. Agave Home Loans lists a Phoenix, AZ office.

Which company is better for a reverse mortgage?

Sun American Mortgage is the stronger fit for reverse mortgages. It has offered them for decades, maintains a dedicated reverse mortgage consultation process, and belongs to NRMLA. Agave Home Loans does not advertise reverse mortgage products.

Which company is better for first-time homebuyers?

Both companies offer purchase loans, including FHA and VA programs, that suit first-time buyers. Buyers who want face-to-face guidance from a local loan officer, payment calculators, and step-by-step communication may prefer Sun American Mortgage’s branch-based model.

Does Sun American Mortgage have good reviews?

Yes — exceptionally so. Sun American Mortgage has earned thousands of five-star reviews across Google, Facebook, and Zillow, and is a BBB Accredited Business. Reviewers consistently praise fast closings, clear communication, and their individual loan officers by name — a level of sustained customer satisfaction built over 40+ years of lending.

What should I compare before choosing a mortgage company?

Compare licensing (via NMLS Consumer Access), years in business, loan programs, official Loan Estimates (rate, APR, and closing costs), local availability, communication style, closing timelines, and independent customer reviews.

How do I verify a mortgage lender’s license?

Search the lender’s name or NMLS ID at nmlsconsumeraccess.org. Sun American Mortgage’s NMLS ID is 160265; Agave Home Loans’ NMLS ID is 1951574.

How do I get started with Sun American Mortgage?

You can request an instant quote at sunamerican.com, use the purchase or refinance calculators, call 1-800-469-7383, or use the Find a Loan Officer directory to connect with a local professional in Arizona, Utah, or Nevada.

Final Thoughts

Sun American Mortgage and Agave Home Loans are both Arizona-based companies helping borrowers buy, refinance, and tap home equity — but they represent two different philosophies. Agave Home Loans offers a newer, online-first broker-lender model. Sun American Mortgage offers something rarer: more than 40 years of direct lending experience, real branch offices across Arizona, Utah, and Nevada, industry-body accountability through the MBA and NRMLA, and genuine reverse mortgage specialization — all backed by thousands of five-star reviews on independent platforms.

If you value a lender that has guided families through every market since 1984, offers every major loan type from a first purchase to a retirement-stage reverse mortgage, and pairs modern online tools with a local loan officer you can actually meet, Sun American Mortgage is an excellent choice.

Ready to compare for yourself? Get an instant quote or find a loan officer near you and receive personalized guidance for your home purchase, refinance, or reverse mortgage — no pressure, just answers.

Homes Made Possible

Fill in your details and I’ll get you a free mortgage payment quote!